Prayers Aren’t Getting Answered The Way You Expected? Understanding Why

 
woman struggling with things not going right
 
 

How is a person to understand what God is doing when things don’t go the way you thought they would - or perhaps even the way you thought he had promised they would? A marriage that you thought was God’s will isn’t working out. A child you’d prayed for dies. A wife can’t get pregnant. An adult child walks away from the faith. Or any other number of things that cause suffering.

Sometimes we think we know what God’s will is (marriage, healing, a baby, rescuing from something), and we think we’re praying for things aligned with his will. And, because of that, we think that God will answer our prayers according to what we think will happen. But then he doesn’t. How do we make sense of that?

There are so many examples in Scripture of people who thought that something good was just around the corner, that God was about to provide, that prayers were going to be answered. And then it didn’t happen, and there was a long season of disappointment and bewilderment. Let’s look at a few examples and see what you can glean about your own situation.

Naomi

Sometimes there are really hard, really long seasons where it feels like we’re far from God (or God is far from us) and things just keep getting worse. The book of Ruth is one example. Here was a woman (Naomi) and her husband and their two sons who lived in Bethlehem (which means “house of bread”), and they found themselves in a famine and fearing that they might die if they didn’t move to a place where there was food (ironic, right?). In what they thought was the best move they could make during that difficult time, they moved to Moab.

Perhaps they left Bethlehem full of praise to God that he was providing for them. Perhaps they felt confident hope that they were going somewhere where there would be plenty and they would all live.

There in Moab, her sons married Moabite women, and perhaps it was happy times and they felt like surely God was providing for them. But her husband died, and when they had lived there 10 years, the sons died, too.

How devastating! Naomi had gone there hoping to flourish and, instead, she faced destruction and agony! What seemed like a good move at the time turned out to be devastating.

Did she have regrets?

Did she think that maybe they never should have left Bethlehem (the house of bread)?

Did she wonder if she was being punished?

Did she think that perhaps God had abandoned her?

We know that she likely thought all of those things because she says “the Lord’s hand has gone out against me,” adding that God had made her life very bitter and empty and that he has afflicted her and brought misfortune upon her. How hopeless!

Despite that, she had Ruth, her faithful daughter-in-law, who dreamed of nothing more than staying with Naomi and being able to help her in any way she could, even offering to go glean from the fields where she could have been harmed. It had been 10 years of pain, and they probably didn’t anticipate it would end, but Ruth was determined to stay by Naomi’s side, never suspecting that God had a plan to flourish them.

In what was no coincidence but could have been only an arrangement by God, Ruth met Boaz who, long story short, agreed to marry her (even skirting another almost-detour when another next of kin could have taken the opportunity to marry her instead), and Ruth and Naomi rested from their distress and felt the favor of God upon them.

From feeling abandoned, fearing for their lives, being worried about being harmed - to feeling favored. And even more than they could have imagined, because Ruth and Boaz gave birth to a baby named Obed who became the father of Jesse who was the father of King David, the predecessor of the Messiah.

The situation that these people from history experienced shows that, surely, God has a plan. Even when things don’t go the way you think they will. Even when you think you’re doing the right thing and are aligned with God’s will and things seem to be not turning out. God has a plan. A better plan.

Maybe it was because God knew that Naomi's husband and sons would die that he sent her to Moab to meet Ruth. Maybe rather than their miserable time in Moab feeling like a punishment, it was God’s way of having Naomi meet Ruth so that Ruth could meet Boaz so that they become the great grandparents of King David. Why such a round-about way? God only knows, but it demonstrates that he hasn’t abandoned or forgotten you.

The lesson here might be that, rather than stressing about whether you heard correctly from God, rather than desperately crying out in prayer for what you think God is going to do, rather than trying to hear from God when he seems silent, just live your life the best you can (like Naomi and Ruth did) and see what God does. After all, prayer isn’t as much about God getting you out of something as it is about inviting God into it.

God has a love for you that you can never understand. And it doesn't matter to him how you are measuring up. It doesn’t matter if you are trying so hard and still failing. God’s plans are not based on your performance. All that matters is that you are his. He loves you and has a plan to get you through this life and then lead you into eternity with him where there will be no more sorrow and no more tears.

Mordecai

Mordecai from the book of Esther also has some encouragement when you are going through a really long season where it feels like you’re far from God (or God is far from you) and things just keep getting worse. His journey shows us that God has a plan to redeem your situation in a way that you can’t see or even imagine.

Mordecai had worked so hard to raise his cousin, Hadassah, when her parents died. Maybe Mordecai thought that God would see his love for Hadassah and have favor on him, but instead of favor, Hadassah was taken forcibly to the palace to be used in service of the king (and she was called Esther). Not what a Jew would want for their daughter!

Perhaps he felt betrayed by God after he’d been so faithful to Hadassah. He’d tried so hard to raise her well and protect her and take care of her, and now she was gone - and in the hands of pagans.

Mordecai worried about her every day and would walk back and forth near the courtyard of the harem to find out how Esther was and what was happening to her. For 4 years he worried and wondered what was going on. Perhaps he raised a fist at God and questioned why he let that happen. As a Jew, he knew that doing good things let to good results and doing bad things led to bad results (after all, he was a product of the exile - living in Persia because his people had done bad things and turned from God). So surely all of the good things he’d done for Esther should have earned him favor, not the exile of his adopted daughter from his home. So many questions. So much out of his control.

After 4 years Esther was presented to the king to see if he would be pleased with her, and she became queen. It sounds great, but not when you are a Jew being forced to marry a pagan. It was going from bad to worse - now she would never be released back to her home and her people!

Perhaps Mordecai became concerned at that point that Esther would have to face the same humiliation (or decision) that queen Vashti had faced. Would she have been chosen only later to be rejected? Would she have to choose between her dignity and her obedience to the king?   

Another 5 years passed and Haman (one of the nobles of Persia) plotted to kill not only Mordecai but all his people (the Jews). Surely Mordecai felt, again, that God had forgotten him and rejected him. But, when Esther was willing and able to use her position to gain the favor of the king and prevent the annihilation of the Jews, it became clear that God had a plan all along.

When we pray in these hard seasons, and when it seems that God is not answering our prayers or that God has given us misery instead of reward for the good that we’ve done, Mordecai’s journey and the disillusionment and fear he felt along the way can help us realize that we are short-sighted. God does have a plan. And he is carrying it out. It’s just not happening the way you think it would. And the result might not even be what you’d thought it would be. It doesn’t feel worth it in the short run, but it will in the long run.

Joseph

Joseph had had a dream that his brothers and parents would bow down to him. He was probably certain that he’d heard from God, and he was pretty excited about it. His father had even reinforced his worthiness by giving him a special robe. He thought only good things were ahead. But then….

He finds himself at the bottom of well, having been put there by the people who were supposed to bow down to him. They sold him as a slave… the very opposite status of the kind of people that others bow down to.

He must have been so confused. “I thought I’d heard from God. Why is this happening? This isn’t the way it’s supposed to go! God, what are you doing?”

Then, after working hard for years in his master’s house and proving his worthiness and integrity, he gets accused of something he didn’t do, and the master who had fully trusted him suddenly betrays him and shames him, putting him into prison without giving him a chance to defend himself. Perhaps he was thinking “I thought this position of trust and authority would lead me out of slavery, but now here I am even lower than a slave: I’m in a dungeon! God, why are you letting this happen? I was supposed to be respected! I worked so hard to earn respect, and all I get is shame!”

Even when he caught glimpses of hope (when he interpreted the dreams of the cup-bearer and the baker for the king) and thought that for sure this was now going to be God’s redemption, he was still let down again. It was YEARS before he would be elevated to the second-in-command in the kingdom of Egypt and have his brothers come and bow before him.

When it’s been years for you of a story you would not have written, circumstances that don’t seem fair, confusion as to why things are happening the way they are - rest in knowing that the One who is writing it is not living in the moment like you are - he is living in the victory. And you can, too.

David

He was called from herding the sheep to be anointed king. He was assigned a position alongside King Saul to be his armor-bearer and to play the harp for him, bring him comfort and protection. But in a turn of events, Saul turned on him and vowed to take his life. David ran from place to place for years in his attempt to hide from Saul. The king was on the move - but not in the way he’d thought he would be. Those were years of questioning God and his plan. Those were years of questioning God’s character. We read all about his thoughts and feelings during that time in the Psalms. But they were also years when God was shaping David’s character into that of a good king whose line would bring forth the Messiah.

Foresight

We know the end of their stories from the beginning, but those who were living it… didn’t. They didn’t know how it was going to turn out. They only knew that there were years of misery and confusion and disappointment and disillusionment and fear.

But you know who knows the end of our story from the beginning? God. We don’t know how it’s going to turn out, but God does. And just like we could go to Naomi or Mordecai or Joseph or David or Elijah or or Job or so many other people in Biblical history and they would say “don’t worry, it’s going to turn out amazing” - God says to us “don’t worry, it’s going to turn out amazing!”

Just because we’re close to God doesn’t mean that he will always give us what we ask for, but it does mean that he will always gives us what is best - best for us in the long term, best for our growth, best for our witness, best for God’s kingdom and his glory.

What Suffering Indicates About Where A Person Stands With God

Please know that just because you suffer doesn't mean that God doesn’t approve of you or that you are being punished or abandoned:

  • Jeremiah the prophet suffered - no one listened to him and he was treated horribly, but God was still with him

  • Naomi suffered the death of her husband and sons - but God still blessed her

  • Job, a man called “blameless” by God, suffered - but God still approved of him and never backed down from his high view of him

  • Esther and Mordecai suffered - but God still used them to save his people

  • David suffered rejection and threats on his life from the king of Israel - but God still raised him to the status of king

  • Paul the apostle of Jesus suffered a “thorn in his flesh” and prayed three times for God to remove it, and he never did - but God still approved of him and gave him a ministry that continues to spread the gospel around the world

  • Joseph (the earthly father of Jesus) suffered the questioning of his reputation and integrity when he stayed married to Mary despite public disapproval - yet God approved of him to be a parent to the Messiah

And just because others (some who may even be “less righteous” than you) get blessings that you don’t or don’t seem to struggle like you do doesn’t mean God turns a blind eye to their sin:

  • Just because Jacob deceived his father and received a blessing doesn’t mean God approved of his lying

  • Just because God made Hagar’s son (Ishmael) a father of nations doesn't mean God approved of Abram’s adultery

  • Just because Abram became rich after lying to the king of Egypt doesn’t mean God blessed him for lying

  • Just because Jephtha kept his promise to sacrifice his daughter (and made it into the Hall of Faith in Hebrews 11) does not mean that God approved of the sin

  • Just because Samson was consecrated to God does not mean God liked him

  • Just because God gave Balak permission to go on the journey doesn’t mean God approved it

  • Just because Barak got victory over Sisera (his enemy) doesn’t mean God approved of him needing Deborah to go with him

  • Just because God protected Cain after he killed his brother doesn’t mean that God approved of murder

  • Just because God provided water from the rock even when Moses did not obey him does not mean that God shrugged off Moses’s sin

Do you know why some people seem to be doing so well in their lives? They have the children they wanted (or maybe children they didn’t even expect). They have great marriages. They have financial stability or wealth. They are healthy and active. Perhaps they are doing well in the areas that it pains you most to see (and that you are jealous of) because that’s what God needed to give them in order for them to struggle and grow. In the areas where they seem to be thriving, that could be where their struggle is - you just don’t see it. To you it looks like there is no struggle there, and so you want what they have - but for them, it’s actually what they needed so they would struggle and grow in the way God needs them to. God allows for us what he know we need in order for us to mature in Christ and know Him more:

  • One person gets pregnant easily because it’s what they need in order to struggle and grow

  • Another person struggles to get pregnant because it’s in that struggle that God plans to mature them in Christ and bring them closer as they get to know Him more

  • One person’s marriage thrives because it’s what they need in order to struggle well through other areas of their lives

  • Another person’s marriage is struggling because it’s in that struggle that God plans to mature them in Christ and bring them closer as they get to know Him more

  • A non-believer’s child turns out to be rich or famous while your child struggles to navigate the challenges of life - all because God knows what we need in order to learn and grow

  • One person is wealthy because God needs them to be wealthy in order to teach them that money doesn’t solve all their problems, or to teach them not to let money be their god

  • Another person struggles to make ends meet because that’s what they need in order to depend on God and not make money their god

The same topic can be experienced by people on opposite ends of the spectrum to accomplish the same goal because God knows us so well that he knows the thoughts and inclinations of our hearts and guides our lives in ways that are uniquely designed for us and him.

What wrong thinking is God trying to address through the situation you are in?

  • You want vindication or justice in an embarrassing situation because it would erase your shame

  • You want redemption for your marriage because it would validate your efforts and your belief that God’s will for your marriage is for it to be saved

  • You want an answered prayer because it would address your need for him to proves that he cares about your desires

  • You want to be pregnant because it would affirm your womanhood

  • You want your adult child to be successful because it would redeem your fear that you weren’t good enough as a parent

  • You want something to go your way in order to erase your fear of being wrong

  • You want good things to happen when you do good things so that you can feel that your goodness has been validated

  • You want financial success so you can feel blessed and worthwhile

  • You want health so that you can believe that God heals

But what God really wants is for you to just trust him.

From Favor To Reproach

Psalm 44 is about how God had given Israel victory and favor - and they had been faithful to praise him - and yet God then seemed to have turned on them and made them a reproach (shame): “All this came upon us, though we had not forgotten you; we had not been false to your covenant. Our hearts had not turned back; our feet had not strayed from your path. But you crushed us and made us a haunt for jackals; you covered us over with deep darkness.”

Naomi, Mordecai, Joseph, David - all thinking, at the start of their journeys, that good things were about to happen. But they had to face the realities of a broken world - and it didn’t feel good - until God brought about something better than they could have imagined. But only after it went the total opposite of the way they thought it would:

  • Naomi thought they were doing the right thing so that they would live - but they died.

  • Mordecai thought that he was saving his cousin - but then she was taken from his protection.

  • Joseph thought he was going to be raised up and bowed down to - but he was put down by the very people who were supposed to bow and sold into slavery and then imprisoned for something he didn’t do after having done all the right things.

  • David thought he was going to be honored as king - but he was shamed and his life was threatened, and he had to hide for years.

  • Elijah thought he was going to be proved right and respected when he prayed and God brought down fire - but instead his life was threatened and he wanted to die.

  • Moses thought he was going to be seen as the one to save his people from slavery - but then he had to exile himself to save his own life and live in the wilderness for 40 years.

  • Job was so blameless that he made sacrifices on behalf of his children so they would be covered in case they’d done something wrong - and he still didn’t avoid tragedy.

But all of their stories ended up working out for their good and God’s glory. So if you are facing a situation today that has you feeling disillusioned, confused, rejected, abandoned, or treated unfairly, remember that….. hope isn’t found in our situation changing, it’s found in our situation…

Do you want some help working through a struggle you are facing? Schedule a Breakthrough Session by clicking the button below:



 
Abigail Wincek

Abigail is the founder of Changing Us, a Board Certified Mental Health Coach through the AACC, a licensed Clinical Substance Abuse Counselor, and a Certified Trauma Professional. Drawing on nearly two decades of counseling experience and her own journey through a toxic marriage, she equips Christians to recognize destructive character, set biblical boundaries, and navigate challenging relationships when conventional marriage advice falls short. Read her full story and credentials at https://www.changingus.org/meet-abigail

https://www.changingus.org
Previous
Previous

The Greek Words For Divorce Will Change How You Think About It

Next
Next

Do Narcissists Know What They’re Doing?